
A major renovation or custom home projectcan be made more organized by an architect and a contractor, but their rolesmust be understood by all three parties. The design, drawings, and technicalintent are developed by the architect.
Those documents are turned into a finishedbuilding by the contractor, while construction, trades, materials, and sitecoordination are managed by the contractor. Both sides are connected by thehomeowner through the establishment of priorities, approval of decisions, andcontrol of the budget.
Problems start when responsibilitiesoverlap, information is lost between teams, or the architect is expected by thehomeowner to manage construction or the contractor is expected to redesign theproject. Rework, confusion, delay, and expensive changes will be avoided bydeveloping a good working relationship right from the start.
An architect's responsibilities depend onthe contract and project scope, but architectural services can include designdevelopment, permitting support, construction documents, consultantcoordination, and construction-phase services. During construction, anarchitect may review submittals, observe work, respond to questions andevaluate whether completed work generally conforms to the contract documents.
The California Architects Board'sprofessional guidance distinguishes the architect's design intent from thecontractor's means and methods. It also recognizes construction-phaseactivities such as reviewing submittals, applications for payment, change ordersand construction progress.
That distinction matters. The architectdetermines what the project should achieve through the design and contractdocuments. The contractor determines how the construction team will execute thework within the applicable requirements.
Depending on the agreement, the architectmay handle initial design concepts, planning space, elevations and floor plans,and construction drawings. Finish and material specifications may also behandled, along with coordination with engineering or structural consultants.
The architect may handle permitdocumentation, construction questions and responses, and review of certaincontractor submittals. Construction observations and design-related changedocumentation may also be included.
Do not assume every architect provides allof these services. The homeowner should review the architectural agreementbefore construction begins. California requires architects to use writtencontracts for architectural services.
Required information includes the project,services, compensation, and procedures for additional services or contractchanges.
WhatDoes the Contractor Do?
The contractor takes the approved designand manages the construction process. A general contractor typicallycoordinates contractors and subcontractors, scheduling construction, andprocurement of material. Supervision of the site, sequencing of construction,and coordination of trades are also included.
Daily construction activities, safety andlogistics at the jobsite, and access and inspections are typically coordinated.Payment administration and construction pricing, along with execution ofchange-order, may also be handled.
California's Contractors State LicenseBoard explains that general building contractors commonly oversee projects andcoordinate specialty subcontractors. The contractor also brings practicalconstruction knowledge into the project.
For example, the architect might specify aparticular finish or assembly, while the contractor identifies an installationissue, availability problem or sequencing concern that needs to be resolved. Thatconversation should happen before the work reaches the affected area.
TheHomeowner Is Still the Decision-Maker
The error that many make believes thathiring the architect and contractor releases the homeowner from involvement inthe project. You still need to makedecisions about project budget, priorities for design, and building materials.
Youalso need to make decisions about priorities for schedule, changes in scope,project allowances, and project upgrades. Change orders and unforeseenconditions may also require decisions. The professional input is provided bythe architect and contractor, but authority to make every decision on yourbehalf is not automatically given to them.
A clear approval process should beestablished before construction starts. For example, a design issue isidentified by the architect, construction/pricing input is provided by thecontractor, and the options are reviewed and the direction is approved by thehomeowner.
Thearchitect or contractor documents the decision, and the contractor proceeds. Thissimple process prevents informal decisions from disappearing intoconversations, text messages or jobsite discussions.
There are several ways to structure therelationship.
Architectfirst, contractor later
The architect completes the design andconstruction documents before the homeowner selects a contractor.
Advantages:
Design gets developed before pricing, andcontractors can bid against a scope defined. The homeowner has more informationbefore committing to construction.
Potentialdrawback:
Construction or pricing issues may beidentified by the contractor only after the design is substantially complete. This approach works well when the homeownerwants to establish the design before selecting the builder.
Architectand contractor collaborate early
The contractor becomes involved while thearchitect is still developing the project. This can allow the contractor toprovide early input on constructability, construction materials, andconstruction sequencing.
Early input can also be provided onconstruction budget, conditions of the site, and material availability.Practical details of construction can also be included in the contractor’searly input.
The benefit is early feedback. The tradeoffis that the homeowner needs to define how early contractor input affects designdecisions and pricing.
Design-build
A design-build company combines design andconstruction under one coordinated delivery structure. This can simplifycommunication because the homeowner has one primary organization managing bothfunctions.
However, the homeowner should stillunderstand who is responsible for architectural services, construction,pricing, permits, design changes and construction administration. The importantissue is not which structure sounds simplest. The important issue is thatresponsibilities are documented.
EstablishOne Communication System
Three-way projects become difficult whencommunication is handled separately by everyone. Consider the scenario wherethe homeowner informs the contractor who then sends a text to the architect whosubsequently emails the homeowner. The following day, the homeowner informs thecontractor differently. Now nobody has a reliable record.
Create one communication process. Forexample, design questions go to the architect, while construction questions andprice and schedule changes go to the contractor and homeowner.
Design changes affecting constructioninvolve the architect, contractor, and homeowner, while final approvals areprovided by the homeowner in writing. Use email, project-management software oranother shared system that keeps decisions accessible to the relevant team.
Givethe Contractor Complete Design Information
Contractors price what they can understand.If the basic layout is shown in the drawings but major selections are leftunresolved, allowances or exclusions may need to be used by the contractor. Thatcreates uncertainty.
Before construction pricing becomes final,clarify as much as practical about cabinet finishes, window finishes, and doorfinishes. Flooring materials, tile materials, and countertop materials shouldalso be clarified. Fixtures and plumbing, lighting fixtures, and appliances andequipment should be clarified as well.
Finishes and exterior, along with built-infeatures, should be considered. Hardware finishes should also be clarifiedbefore construction pricing becomes final. A contractor cannot accurately pricea product that nobody has specified.
Allowancesneed special attention
An allowance is used as a budgetplaceholder for an item that has not yet been fully selected or priced. This isbecause the budgeted cost for a bathroom plumbing fixture of $X does notautomatically ensure that the actual cost will be $X.
If a more expensive product is selectedlater by the homeowner, the project price can be increased. Ask what is coveredby each allowance and what installation costs remain outside it.
Havethe Architect and Contractor Review the Plans Together
Before construction begins, a formal reviewof the drawings should be scheduled. The goal is not to redesign the house atthe last minute. Instead, look for conflicts such as elements of structure,locations of plumbing, and equipment for HVAC.
Requirements for electrical, dimensions ofcabinets, and swings of doors should also be checked. Heights of ceilings,conditions of windows, and transitions of finish should be reviewed forconflicts. Clearances for equipment should also be checked.
The contractor can identify practicalconstruction issues that might not be obvious from the drawings. The architectcan clarify the intended design when the contractor encounters an ambiguousdetail. This meeting is particularly valuable before demolition and beforeordering expensive custom materials.
DefineWho Answers Construction Questions
Questions will arise during construction. Thecontractor may find an existing condition that does not coincide with thedrawing such as existing plumbing in the wall which will interfere with the newopening.
The contractor needs a clear path forresolving that problem. A useful process is for the condition to be documentedby the contractor and the design implications to be evaluated by the architect. Construction and cost implications areexplained by the contractor, and the available options are reviewed by thehomeowner.
The decision is documented by theresponsible parties, and authorization is provided before the contractorproceeds. This prevents the jobsite from becoming the place where major designdecisions happen informally.
KeepChange Orders under Control
Not every change represents poor projectmanagement. Renovations can uncover genuine conditions that nobody could seebefore demolition. The problem occurs when homeowners make discretionarychanges without understanding the cost and schedule impact.
For example, if a standard kitchenbacksplash is changed to specialty tile, consider the material difference,whether installation labor or the schedule will change, and whether the changewill affect adjacent finishes.
California CSLB guidance requires changesto home-improvement contracts to be documented through written change orders,with the change becoming part of the contract. Do not rely on a verbalagreement such as “We'll figure out the price later”.
This distinction prevents many arguments. Thearchitect establishes the design requirements. The contractor determines themeans and methods used to construct the work, subject to the contractdocuments, applicable codes and professional responsibilities.
For example, an architect may require aparticular finished appearance or performance characteristic. The contractormay select an appropriate construction sequence or installation method thatachieves the documented requirement.
If the contractor proposes a substitution,the team should determine whether it meets the design requirement andapplicable code. The team should also determine whether it affects appearance,performance, warranty, or schedule, or changes cost.
The contractor should not make a designsubstitution simply because it is easier to install. Likewise, the architectshould understand the construction consequences of a design decision.
You need to understand both agreements—notjust the construction contract. The architect's agreement should explain thearchitectural services, compensation and procedures for additional services.California's Architects Board specifically requires writtenarchitectural-service contracts in applicable circumstances.
The contractor's home-improvement contractshould describe the construction scope, materials, price, payment schedule,permit responsibilities and completion terms. California CSLB requires writtencontracts for home-improvement projects over $500 and requires contract changesto be documented in writing.
Look for gaps between the two. For example,the architect may assume permit coordination will be handled by the contractor,while the contractor may assume permits will be handled by the homeowner. Thatgap can create delays before construction even begins.
Createa Responsibility Matrix
One of the easiest ways to eliminateconfusion is to have ownership of each task written down. The architect leadsthe design concept, while the contractor provides input and the homeownerapproves it. The architect leads the construction drawings, while thecontractor provides review/input and the homeowner approves them.
The contractor leads contractor pricing,while the architect provides input and the homeowner reviews it. The contractorleads the construction schedule, while the architect provides input and thehomeowner reviews it. Materials are specified by the architect, usuallycoordinated or ordered by the contractor, and approved by the homeowner.
Jobsite management is led by thecontractor, while the architect observes or coordinates per contract and thehomeowner monitors. Design questions are led by the architect, raised by thecontractor, and approved by the homeowner when changes are needed. Thecontractor leads construction methods, while the architect is consulted asappropriate.
Change orders receive design input from thearchitect, are priced and documented by the contractor, and are approved by thehomeowner. Final selections are specified or recommended by the architect,priced with input by the contractor, and decided by the homeowner.
Payments are reviewed by the architect ifcontracted, submitted by the contractor, and approved or paid by the homeowner.The exact division should follow the signed contracts.
The architect and the contractor give youconflicting instructions, and you don’t know which one has the authority toallow the changes. Outdated drawings are regularly used by the contractor forconstruction. Material substitutions happen without being documented. Youreceive unexpected invoices for work that is supposedly included.
Design questions remain unanswered for longperiods of time. Jobsite decisions happen without the homeowner being informed.The schedule changes without a documented explanation being provided.
Each party tries to blame the other ratherthan solving the problem, and you do not know which drawings are current. Theseproblems become more expensive as construction progresses. Address them early.
In order for a large-scale home renovationor custom home project to be successful, one needs to first establish one’sgoals through writing down what one wants to accomplish, what is mostimportant, and what budgetary limitations there are. One hires the architectthrough the written scope of the architecture.
Develop the design by resolving the majorlayout and design decisions before requesting serious construction pricing.Involve the contractor at the appropriate stage by deciding whether you wantcontractor input during design or competitive pricing after the designdocuments are sufficiently developed.
Coordinate the documents by having thearchitect and contractor identify conflicts before construction begins. Set upthe communication policy by establishing who is to answer questions aboutdesign, construction, cost, and approval issues. Establish the constructioncontract by ensuring that the scope, materials, payments, permits, schedule,and change process are all established.
Follow the formal process of changes withdesign changes, substitution, cost, and schedule impacts documented first.Maintain one current drawing set by not allowing outdated plans to circulate atthe jobsite. Project review sessions must be conducted through progressreviews, selection to come, decision-making, budget revisions, and outstandingproblems.
FAQ
ShouldI hire an architect or contractor first?
The project's layout, design direction, anddocumentation can be established by hiring the architect first for adesign-intensive renovation or custom home. For certain types of projects,involvement of contractors in the design stage can be very helpful, especiallyfor getting feedback on constructability and budgets.
Canan architect and contractor work together?
Yes. Construction projects are routinelyworked on together, but different responsibilities are assigned to each. Theresponsibilities concerning design and documentation as per the architecturalagreement are done by the architect, while the construction process is takencare of by the contractor.
Shouldmy contractor talk directly to my architect?
Yes. Direct communication can preventmisunderstandings, especially when construction questions involve the design.The homeowner should still know what decisions were made and which changesaffect cost or schedule.
Whois responsible when the contractor finds a problem in the plans?
The answer depends on the contracts and thenature of the problem. The issue should be raised by the contractor rather thanan unapproved design change being made. Design issues can be answered by thearchitect whereas construction, costs, and scheduling issues can be answered bythe contractor.
Shouldan architect supervise the contractor?
Not automatically. Architecturalconstruction-phase services can include site observations and review ofconstruction information, but that does not make the architect the contractor'sjobsite manager. The scope of architectural services should clearly state whatconstruction-phase involvement the architect provides.
Howdo I prevent disagreements between my architect and contractor?
Responsibilities should be defined beforeconstruction, one current set of drawings should be used, a communicationprocess should be established, decisions should be documented, and writtenchange orders should be required for changes that affect the contract. Exactlywhich decisions require homeowner approval should also be understood by thehomeowner.
FinalThoughts
The same role does not need to be held byan architect and contractor for effective teamwork to be achieved. Thearchitect brings design expertise and documents the project's intended result.The contractor brings construction expertise, manages the trades and turns thedocuments into physical work.
The homeowner sets priorities, approvesimportant decisions and controls the relationship. The strongest projectscreate clear boundaries without creating communication barriers. Bring thecontractor into design discussions when practical. Give the architect completeinformation about construction questions.
Keep pricing and scope changes documented.Maintain one current set of drawings. Most importantly, it should never beassumed that a responsibility is being handled by someone else simply becauseit seems obvious. Once one knows who makes the decisions, writes the papers,does the building, and signs off, then managing the project from its beginningdrawings to its end walkthrough will be made easier.
California-specific contract, licensing,and project requirements should be verified against the current requirements ofthe California Architects Board, Contractors State License Board, and localbuilding department before publication or construction.